A Blog of Toronto Blue Jays Prospects Interviews, Evaluations and News

Blue Jays Draft Max Pentecost 11th Overall

Considered one of the best college hitters in the entire draft

Blue Jays Draft Max Pentecost 11th Overall

June 6, 2014

Max Pentecost

Catcher / 21 years old / 6’2″ 190 lbs.

Born: March 10, 1993

Bats/Throws: Right/Right

High School: Winder-Barrow (Winder, GA)

College: Kennesaw State

Baseball America Top 100 Draft Rank: 17

Mock Draft Rankings:

Baseball America (John Manuel): 9

Baseball Prospectus (Perfect Game): 16

MLB.com (Jim Callis): 12

MLB.com (Jonathan Mayo): 12

ESPN (Keith Law): 19

  • Ranked No. 16 on Perfect Game’s top 500 draft list
  • Draws comparisons to Jason Kendall
  • Finalist for the prestigious Johnny Bench Award
  • Ranked the top prospect from Georgia in the draft
  • Passes current Blue Jay Chad Jenkins as highest-drafted player in Kennesaw State history
  • Considered the top catcher in the draft
  • Had a 36-game hitting streak this past season

Nearly six months to the day after the Blue Jays parted ways with J.P. Arencibia—the last of four catchers to leave the organization over the past few seasons—they regained some valuable catching depth on Thursday night by selecting 21-year-old Max Pentecost out of Kennesaw State University. The 11th-overall pick used to sign Pentecost was given to the Jays for failing to sign right-handed pitcher Phil Bickford last year.

Considered by Baseball America to be one of the best college hitters in the entire draft, Pentecost almost turned pro three years ago.

As Pentecost worked his way through high school, something didn’t feel right. His throwing arm starting hurting in his sophomore year and continued to bother him up until one of his final games as a senior, when he felt a pop. Initially projected as a top-three rounds pick, Pentecost’s elbow surgery caused him to fall to the Texas Rangers in the seventh round.

Turning down the Rangers and fulfilling his commitment to Kennesaw State turned out to be the best decision Pentecost could have made, as the Georgia native was drafted by the Blue Jays at a position that has a recommended slot value of $2,888,300. While the Blue Jays will likely try to save some bonus pool allotment dollars when attempting to sign Pentecost, there shouldn’t be any concerns about signing him.

After hitting .277 with a .756 OPS in his freshman year at Kennesaw State, it was the arrival of new hitting coach Derek Simmons for the 2013 season that really helped Pentecost take his offensive game to the next level. Simmons dubbed Pentecost the best breaking hitter he has seen in an interview with Baseball America and mentioned some of the tweaks he made to Pentecost’s body at the plate.

More draft coverage from JaysProspects
9th-overall pick RHP Jeff Hoffman
Second-round pick RHP Sean Reid-Foley

“He was really struggling getting his back side through, and so we kind of corrected his stance a little bit,” Simmons said in the interview. “He really took off halfway through the year last year, and it really carried over to the Cape, and it’s carrying over now too . . . His hands were always good, but it’s just his lower half really wasn’t in sync with his upper half.”

The changes paid immediate dividends, as Pentecost hit .302 with a .785 OPS and three home runs as a sophomore with the Owls. Last summer, Pentecost took his game to new heights with an improved mental approach in the Cape Cod League, en route to being named league MVP for his impressive .346/.424/.538 slash lane.

That improved mindset carried over to his junior year in a big way in 2014 as well. Pentecost led his Owls team in nearly every offensive category including batting average (.423), hits (110), doubles (23), home runs (9), on-base percentage (.483), slugging percentage (.631) and stolen bases (17). The fact that Pentecost went 17-for-19 in stolen base attempts should really stick out, as it’s a testament to his athleticism and a rarity for a catcher nowadays.





Here’s additional information from first-hand sources on Max Pentecost:

Baseball America:

“Pentecost’s athleticism stood out then and still does after catching for most of the last three seasons. Scouts consider him an above-average runner, fairly exceptional for a catcher, and his 6-foot-1, 190-pound body could use more strength to hold up under the rigors of catching 100-plus games. The body and his speed earn him Jason Kendall comparisons. He’s an average receiver with average arm strength with inconsistent throwing mechanics and profiles as an offensive catcher. […] Scouts like his line-drive swing, which has improved over the course of his college career. Most scouts see him as a below-average power producer but some see enough feel for hitting for Pentecost to reach 12-15 homers eventually.”


“Taking Max had nothing to do with any of those trades or getting rid of any of those players,” Blue Jays director of amateur scouting Brian Parker said. “When you pick nine and 11, you just have to line up your board and take the best player, and that’s what we did. We like Max. We scouted him pretty hard from last summer in the Cape and throughout this spring.

“This is a guy we have above-average catching grades on,” Blue Jays director of amateur scouting Brian Parker said. “We think this guy can be an asset behind the plate for us. We’ve done some research, we talked to some of his teammates from the Cape, some of the guys he’s played with in the past, and they all rave about him.”


“Offensively, Pentecost has a line-drive swing that stays through the zone with good bat speed and transfers his weight well to generate average power, mostly to the pull side. He’s shown an ability to work counts and a willingness to hit the ball the other way, so high averages and on-base percentages are not out of the question. His swing is more geared towards contact; but 15-18 homer seasons are not out of the question.

Where Pentecost has improved the most since he was a prep, however, is behind the plate. He’s an above-average athlete who runs well for the position, and has shown an ability to block pitches in the dirt. His overall arm strength is only average, but he uses his athleticism and quick release to get rid of the ball quickly and he should do a decent job of keeping base-runners from running.

There isn’t one skill that jumps out when you watch Pentecost, and if you look at the 20-80 grades you might think he looks very mundane; but those can be a bit misleading. An everyday catcher who can get on base and produce average power totals and won’t kill you with the glove is something that every club covets and it’s why Pentecost has a chance to go very early come draft day. One concern is that Pentecost has faced less-than-stellar competition at Kennesaw State, but the tools translate very well and there’s a great chance he’s a first-round pick this year.”

Jared Macdonald

Jared Macdonald

Jared is the editor-in-chief of JaysProspects. A credentialed media member with each affiliate in Toronto's minor league system, he has seen nearly every Blue Jays prospect in person, using information from coaches, scouts, and players to add to his content on the site. His work has been featured in the Toronto Star and on MLB Trade Rumors, among others.